Friday, February 10, 2023

WHO IS GOD? (DEFINITION PLEASE!)



WHO IS GOD?

(DEFINITION PLEASE!)

Brett A. Todd



Christians confess that Jesus is

“dominum nostrum”, our Lord, our

God. But what does this mean when

there is no biblical definition for the

word “God” in the Bible?



Nowhere in the early Semitic writings, which includes the Hebrew Scriptures, is the word, “god” defined. For them, god is god and nothing else matters, only “Fools say in their hearts, 'There is no God'” (Psalm 14:1). As you might guess, this is a problem for the modern Bible reader when trying to answer the question, “Who Is God?” How can you answer such a question when you don't even know what the word “god” means? If you are going to call someone or something a god, then you better know what the word means.  Actually, the closest we come to a definition of God in the Bible is when God says, “I am who I am” (Exodus 3:14) which basically means that God is undefinable.


Recognizing this problem, some Bible scholars have opted for the approach of “looking backward” to answer the question, “Who is God?” How does this work? For them, since Jesus is God and is the perfect representation of God, then all one has to do is look at Jesus first to know God and God's characteristics. In other words, if you know Jesus and his ministry, then you will automatically know God. Using some rather blunt and faulty grammar to get my point across, for these scholars, “What Jesus is, God is. You know God and God's characteristics by knowing Jesus.”


The problems with this approach are too vast to discuss at this time. However, and more importantly, is the fact that Jesus never claimed to be God. So, the idea that one can look at Jesus and then know God is quite a fanciful idea. Further, we are still ignoring the big white elephant in the room, we don't have a definition for the word “God” in the Bible.


Other theologians in search of a definition of “God” have chosen to rummage through the Bible to find Bible verses describing God's divine characteristics or may we say God's nature. However, this picking and choosing method often leads to false information. For example, most Christians would agree that God is love (1 John 4:8), but what about such Bible stories in which this same God of love commanded the Temple guards to slaughter everyone, including women and children? (Ezekiel 9:6). Does this sound like an all-loving God? Of course not, there is nothing just or loving about killing children. So, as you can see, picking and choosing Bible verses has its negative side to it when trying to answer the question, “Who is God?”


The Bible reader needs to understand that what one book of the Bible might say about God may not be the same in another book of the Bible. Again, there is no unified teaching concerning God and God's characteristics in the Bible. Different authors say different things about God. Sometimes these authors agree, other times they disagree. So who is god? Well, that all depends on which book in the Bible you are reading.


What we do know from early Semitic writings, which include the Hebrew Scriptures is that there are a lot of entities called God. Biblical scholar, Mark S. Smith, has tallied the following list of Gods. They include major and minor deities, demons, dead kings and some living kings, monstrous cosmic enemies, or the dead more generally, deities images, standing stones, and other cultic items and places, as well as stars and legendary heroes.


The characteristic that stands out for each one of these Gods listed above is their supposed “mystical otherness”. They may or may not look like humans but all of these Gods were reported as having done something that the average human has not. But how helpful is this to understand the word “God”? Not too helpful. Remember, according to Smith's research, even a human or a stone can fit this description of mystical otherness.


Smith's list of Gods should not surprise the average Bible reader, not only are these same entities mentioned in the Bible, but the First Commandment of the Ten Commandments strictly forbids the worship of any of them, “...you shall have no Gods before me” (Exodus 20:3). Note, it does not say that there are no other Gods, it just says that you cannot worship them in any form. Verses 4 through 5 continue this commandment by saying, “you shall not make for yourself an idol, whether in the form of anything that is in heaven above or that is on the earth beneath or that is in the water under the earth. You shall not bow down to them or serve them, for I the LORD your God am a jealous God.”


It would seem obvious to these ancient people a definition for the word “God” was not important. Again, God is God and nothing else matters. However, it was important for them that they were worshipping the right God (s).


Friday, February 3, 2023

WHO IS GOD? (INTRO)




WHO IS GOD? (INTRO)
Brett A. Todd


Since the 18th century, scholars have been searching for the historical Jesus, when they have yet to answer the most significant question of all, “Who is God?

 

As I mentioned in the previous article, the question, “Who is God?” might seem easy to answer, but it is not. Actually, it is a very complicated, “bigger than us” type of question. So, what we have learned in Sunday school is not sufficient. It's a good start, you have to start somewhere, right? The problem is most people stop there while their pastors and churches continue to nurse them with these same “naive” Sunday school ideas.


I should be clear to the reader that I'm using the words “Sunday School” in a metaphorical manner to communicate the idea of an elementary, or should we say, a simplistic understanding of God and the Bible which are in many ways, inaccurate. Even more so, these simplistic notions go beyond the doors of the church to their institutions of higher learning.


Thinking back to my Fundamentalist College days, we took all of these Sunday school ideas a step further to perfection by memorizing the attributes of God and more. God is Omnipresent, Omnipotent, Omniscient, Eternal, Immutable... “Ah! Now we know God. We have finally arrived.” However, all we learned were the technical words for the theories we learned in Sunday school.


So, where do we start? First, we need to acknowledge that there are a lot of different ideas about God and the Bible. In the United States alone, there are over 200 church denominations, and around the world, there are a whopping 45,000 denominations that believe in something different from all the other church denominations. This is also true of Bible scholars and theologians, and there are a lot of them, who all have different ideas and views of God. Is God all-powerful? Some would say “yes” while others would say “no”. Is God all-knowing? Again, some would say “yes” while others would say “no”. We could go on and on with these kinds of questions, and yes, there would be all sorts of answers. Let's face it, the question, “Who is God?” is big and complicated and there are no shortcuts.


We also find a wide range of answers to the question, “Who is God?” in the Bible. There is no one unified answer. Is God a God of love or revenge or maybe both? Is God spirit or does God have body parts, you know, arms, hands, legs, feet, and nose? Does God eat and drink? Even more revealing, does God, like humans, have regrets and repent for God's wrongdoings? Does God get angry, laugh, cry, get jealous, and become happy or sad? Does God feel pain like humans feel pain? Does God sin or is God perfect? Does God need our help? Or, is God beyond all of this? Sometimes the answer is “yes” while other times it is “no”. It all depends on your culture, religion, and which book of the Bible you are reading. There is no “one size fits all”.


For some, all of this might seem alarming. What does this mean for my faith and practice to begin delving into the unknown by asking, once again, “Who is God?” Will I lose my faith? Will God still love me? These are good, and yes, expected concerns, but keep in mind, questions are healthy and not damning.  Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel once said, “We are closer to God when we are asking questions than when we think we have the answer.” Personally, I see the question, “Who is God?” as an invitation for growth as well as an invitation to see God “face to face” and to know God in truth. I see it as a time for renewal.


To set the stage for the following articles, I will argue that humans' understanding of God has been and will always be in constant fluctuation and development. Some of those changes are quite significant and for some, startling. From the beginning, humans have received little snapshots of God to help them refine and redefine their views of God. These snapshots continue to this day. As the Apostle Paul once said, “For now we see only a reflection...Now I only know in part...” (1 Corinthians 13:12).


It should be obvious to the reader that in these short articles, I will not be able to do justice to the topic at hand.  Rather, this format is to help non-trained Bible scholars understand scholarly studies of the Bible. My goal is to make you think and ask questions.

Wednesday, January 25, 2023

WHO IS GOD? (A LITTLE BIT ABOUT ME)



WHO IS GOD?
 (A LITTLE BIT ABOUT ME)
Brett A. Todd


I took a little break from my little blog, “This Is Not Sunday School”. Now I'm ready to start writing again and I hope you are ready to read and think. In the next few articles, I will attempt to answer the question, “Who is God?” The question might seem easy to answer, but it is not. The question is bigger and more complicated than what one has been taught in Sunday school. However, before I begin, I have been reminded that for some, my articles are a little controversial, and maybe, a little heretical. So, before I approach the question, “Who is God?” I want to discuss my historical approach and maybe even ease the minds of those who may think my articles are controversial or even heretical.

I don't want to get into the details of my education, but my studies hail from Trinity and Northwestern University/Garrett Evangelical Seminary. Northwestern University and Garrett-Evangelical Seminary are sister institutions of higher education with strong Methodists roots. Professors in the field of Hebrew and New Testament, and theology are shared by both institutions. My mentor was Robert Jewett, a world-renowned New Testament scholar, who was also the New Testament scholar at the prestigious University of Tubingen, in Baden-Wurttemberg, Germany. My theology professor was James E. Will, he was a student of Paul Tillich. Dr. Will and Dr. Jewett have had a big impact on my research in New Testament studies and Philosophical Theology. Therefore, it should surprise no one that I am a Hegelian New Testament scholar at heart. Another field of study I spend an insurmountable time in is New Testament Textual Criticism. Daily, I am translating and examining ancient manuscripts, it is my passion. We will talk more about this down the road. I also work with several biblical languages as well as Spanish and English. One of my Greek professors used to tell me that my Greek was better than my English. I don't know if that was criticism or praise, but probably a little of both. Hopefully, this will give you a small blueprint of my thinking and writings.

Concerning the nature of my writings. Are they controversial and heretical? Well, that depends on who you ask. I know that I have been written off by Evangelical Bible Thumpers who may think I'm incarnate of the devil, and that is okay, whatever. However, it is important to understand that what I have and will share in my articles are the very things that have been taught in mainline seminaries for over a hundred years. This means, if your pastor attended a United Methodist, United Church of Christ, Evangelical Lutheran Church, United Presbyterian Church, Episcopalian, etc. seminary they were taught these same things I have been sharing with you. Now, whether they were listening or not in their classes, is another story. I'm also aware that some pastors are afraid to teach what they were taught in seminary for fear of losing their job. Either way, for a pastor not to share and use what they were taught in seminary, is really a disgrace and it is also a big part of why so many churches today are dying. COVID is not the problem, the problem is that too many pastors and churches are still living in Sunday school.

What is my approach to the Bible? I use what is called the historical approach. What I mean by this is that I look at the Bible in light of all the evidence to understand and interpret the Bible. For example, did Matthew the tax collector write the Book of Matthew? By looking at all the evidence from the Book of Matthew, the answer is quite clear, no. Matthew did not write the Gospel of Matthew. In fact, we don’t know who wrote any of the four Gospels.

So, are my articles controversial and maybe even heretical? For those who want to continue living in Sunday school, the answer is maybe. But for those who want to hear what the Bible has in store for seeking minds, the answer is no. Rather, it is a whole new world of learning, discovery, and excitement.


Friday, November 18, 2022

The Eye Of A Needle

 


The Eye Of A Needle (Mark 10:25)
Brett A. Todd


If you have ever spent time reading the New Testament of the Bible, more than likely you came across the words of Jesus, “It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God.” (Mark 10:25). Bible scholars agree, there is no question that Jesus said these words, but there are those gullible preachers who have and continue spread a wishful interpretation in order to sound dynamic and educated. For them, the eye of a needle was actually a small gate in Jerusalem where camels had to crawl on their knees to fit through the gate into the city of Jerusalem. There's one problem with this popular “educated” and “dynamic” interpretation, it is not true. There is not one shred of archaeological evidence that such a gate ever existed in Jerusalem.

Where did they get this interpretation? The furthest back we can go with this interpretation is to that of Theophylact, a Byzantine archbishop of the Middle Ages (around 1055 – after 1107 CE) who wrote a Bible commentary. Some have suggested that his interpretation came from the early Church Fathers, however, there is no such evidence that goes any further back than Theophylact himself.

Simply, Jesus' words about the eye of a needle are actually an exaggeration to catch the attention of his followers. It is a hyperbole. As you read the words of Jesus throughout the four Gospels, you will discover that he used this type of speech a lot. Here is another example found in Luke 6:41, Jesus said, “Why do you see the speck in your neighbor's eye but do not notice the log in your own eye?” And yes, there are more... Jesus loved to use this effective teaching method. Jesus used a lot of hyperboles. Adela Yarbro Collins writes:

The hyperbolic character of the saying catches the attention of the audience effectively and leads them to confront seriously the problem with wealth as a hindrance to entering the kingdom.

Did other ancient writers use such exaggerations to connect with their students and readers? Yes, for example, in early Judaism we find such statements where it is an elephant, not a camel, that had to go through the eye of a needle (See Witherington III).

In our next study, we will answer the question of whether or not Jesus was a pure Jew.




Friday, November 11, 2022

Jesus The Messiah With A Little Caveat


Jesus The Messiah
With A Little Caveat

Brett A. Todd



Did Jesus believe that he was the long-awaited Messiah?  This is a completely different question than asking, did Jesus believe he was God?  God and Messiah are not interchangeable titles but Messiah and King often refer to the same person, like King David in the Bible who is called the king and anointed one (the Messiah). Psalm 28:8 referring to King David reads, “The Lord is the strength of his people; he is the saving refuge of his anointed.”  Yes, the title Messiah means “the anointed one”.  


Did Jesus believe he was the Messiah, the anointed one (the King)?  Yes.  Among scholars, there really isn't much of a debate on this matter.  This is how Mark 15:32 narrates this Jesus title, “Let the Messiah, the king of the Jews, come down from the cross now...”


You may remember the story of when Jesus stood before Pilate.  Pilate asked Jesus point blank if he was the King of the Jews.  Jesus' answer is interesting, he said, “You say so.”  Which means that yes I am but I don't need to say because you already did (Mark 15:2). Further, all four Gospels agree, above the head of Jesus on the cross hung a sign that read, “King of the Jews” (Mark 15:26).  So once again, did Jesus believe he was the Messiah, the King of the Jews?  More than likely, yes, and he died for it as well.


Here is a little caveat, Jesus was not the first person to claim to be the Messiah.  You may remember, even in the Gospels there is a warning that many will claim to be the Messiah (Matthew 24:5).  But there were even those before Jesus who claimed to be the Messiah.


Back in 2000, archaeologists discovered what some scholars believe to be the most important archaeology find since the Dead Sea Scrolls in 1946/7.  Along the banks of the Dead Sea, they found a stone, now called “Gabriel's Stone”, with peculiar writing.  One can view this magnificent stone now displayed at the Israel Museum in Jerusalem.


Why is this stone so significant?  This 4th-1st century BCE stone, or earlier, refers to a messiah who will die and rise from the dead in three days.  In Hebrew, it reads, “In three days, live”  Of course, this stone is not referring to the Jesus of the New Testament. Instead, according to  Israel Knohl, a professor of Biblical studies at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem believes this refers to Simon Peraea (4 BCE).


What does all of this mean?  Long before Jesus came along, there was a certain expectation that a Messiah King would come and deliver them, the Jews, from captivity.  Jesus was just one of those individuals who believed he too was the Messiah King.  More than likely,  Christians borrowed this same idea of the Messiah dying and being raised from the dead on the third day from the same source those who wrote Gabriel's Stone got theirs.  Maybe the old proverb from Ecclesiastes is right, “...there is nothing new under the sun.”


In our next study, we will look at the words of Jesus, “It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God.”  What was Jesus talking about, an actual camel and an eye of a needle, or was it a gate found in Jerusalem?


Friday, November 4, 2022

IS THE MAN THE HEAD OF THE WOMAN? (Part 3)




IS THE MAN THE HEAD OF THE WOMAN? (Part 3)

Brett A. Todd



Sometimes I think if the Apostle Paul had any smarts, he would have never penned some of the things he wrote.  But of course, he lived in a different time and culture.  One example is found in 1 Corinthians 11:3 where he said, “But I want you to understand that Christ is the head of every man, and the man, is the head of the woman.”  Some translations read that “...the husband is the head of his wife.” Whatever translation one accepts, for the modern man and woman, Paul's words are not appealing.  Either way, “man” and “woman” is probably the best rendering of this text.


One might ask, however, what did the Greek word for “head” (of a woman) mean during Paul's time? There are a few opinions on this matter.  Let me mention two of them: 


First is the traditional definition which is widely accepted by scholars.  For them, the word “head” represents authority.  However, for some, this definition is gorged with male chauvinism. So, others have come up with a second suggestion that the Greek word for “head” is more accurately defined as “the source”, like the source of the river. Here it means that man is the source of a woman's existence since a woman (Eve) was made from man (Adam). These same scholars are quick to point out that this definition carries with it no sense of authority or of one person ruling over another.  


Let's pause for a moment and ask, “Really?”  Do these male Bible scholars really think this is going to appease the modern women of our day?  “Women, I have good news for you, men are not the head of women, they are just the source of your existence.  Without them, you would not exist.” 


From a scholarly perspective, there is a significant problem with this idea of a man as the source of a woman’s existence. Every Greek lexicon (Dictionary), except for two, defines this Greek word as someone having a superior rank.  The only two lexicons that offers the idea of a man as the “source” is Liddell and Scott as well as Schlier's in the TDNT. However, they offer no example of this use in Greek literature. From my research, I cannot find such an idea for this Greek word.



Why then would some scholars translate this Greek word as “source”?  It seems in their hasty effort to tame Paul for the modern Bible reader of male chauvinism, several male Christian scholars have designed a way to assure women that the Bible, Paul, and Christianity are on their side. However, in their effort to tame Paul, they seem to have no idea that this idea is still demeaning and outdated for the modern woman.


It is best, to be honest with ourselves and the Bible and recognize that this ancient literature holds many,  ideas that are improper, sinful, and even inhuman when dealing with God's creation, such as racism, classism, ableism, heterosexism, and here, sexism. All of this and more were a part of the Bible's culture.  Yes, Paul was wrong. 


In our next study, we will discuss whether or not Jesus believed he was the Kingly Messiah.  We will also look at an archeological find that many Bible readers are not aware of that may support this idea of a kingly messiah in the Bible.


Friday, October 28, 2022

THE EARLY CHURCH'S VIEW OF WOMEN IN THE CHURCH: SHOULD WOMEN SHOULD BE SILENT IN THE CHURCH. (PART 2)



THE EARLY CHURCH'S VIEW OF WOMEN IN THE CHURCH: SHOULD WOMEN SHOULD BE SILENT IN THE CHURCH. (PART 2)

Brett A. Todd


The infamous words of “Paul” that women are supposed to be silent in the church have had a long-lasting effect on the church, even into these modern times.  You probably know this passage as well as anyone.  1 Corinthian 14:34 reads, “Women should be silent in the churches.  For they are not permitted to speak but be subordinate [to men?]...”  Obviously “Paul” never heard of women’s rights or the “Me Too” movement.


How are we supposed to understand these words?  Bible scholars have long debated these words and have come up with several different answers that you might or might not agree with:  1)Traditionally, many scholars through the years simply believed that what Paul said is what he said, women should be silent in the church, period.  Now they may add to this thought that this was the culture of the time and now we live in a culture where women are more educated and should now be allowed to speak in the church.


2) Other Bible scholars are of the opinion that Paul is quoting what some other men said in some of the house churches in Corinthian but were without question wrong.  Women don’t have to be silent in the church.  The hinge pin to this argument is that later Paul scolds these men in verse 36 by basically saying “Where did you get this great revelation?” This is how verse 36 reads, “Did the word of God originate with you? Or are you the only ones it has reached?”  It is Paul’s slap slap in the face for these early Christian male-chauvinist men.


3) Some other modern scholars have a different twist on these words found in verse 36 that seem to make a lot of sense.  They believe these words (women should be silent in the church) were added later by scribes to keep women subordinate to men, and yes, silent in the church. They note that in other ancient Greek manuscripts these words in verse 36 are located in different locations in 1 Corinthians which is a possible indication that these words were added later.  In other words, these words “women are to be silent in the church” are fraudulent words added by some scribe and not the words of the Apostle Paul.


As I look at these hotly debated words, I think it is self-evident that more than likely, no matter what argument one is inclined to, Paul's thoughts on the matter were probably not too far off from the idea that women should be silent in the church. Yes, today, most modern thinkers would view the Apostle Paul as a male chauvinist or a misogynist.


This is not the end of the story.  Sometime back a scholar at the University of Cambridge was examining this same verse where women are told to be silent in the church and saw something other scholars had missed.  What did this scholar see?  It was a tiny little ancient dash called “distigme-obelos” that indicates this verse was added to Paul’s original words.  Now, this tiny little dash was not found in some obscure ancient Greek manuscript, it was found in one of the oldest and most reliable manuscripts, called the Codex Vaticanus.


Where does this leave us? More than likely, Paul never penned the words that women are to be silent in the church.  Nevertheless, it would not surprise me that he would have agreed with it.


In our next study, we will add “part 3” to our discussion concerning the early church’s view of women in the church.  I was asked for my opinion concerning the Apostle's usage of the word “head” when he said that man was the “head” of the woman (1 Corinthians 11:3).  This should be a fun Scripture to look at.


WHO IS GOD? Spirit Or Body Parts? (PART 5)

WHO IS GOD? Spirit Or Body Parts? (PART 5) Brett A. Todd Wait a minute, are you trying to tell me that God, the big guy in the sky, had a ph...